Email marketing CTA design: five good vs. six bad examples

Email stays some of the efficient instruments within the digital marketing toolbox, with the potential to ship a fantastic return on funding.

Data taken from the Econsultancy Email Marketing Census 2014 exhibits that sixty eight% of corporations price the channel as ‘good’ or ‘wonderful’ for ROI.

One of crucial elements of e mail design is an efficient name-to-motion, because it must encourage recipients into partaking additional together with your model.

We’ve beforehand written about CTA design in regards to ecommerce sites, and most of the similar guidelines apply, however I thought it might be helpful to reiterate a number of the extra essential standards in addition to pulling collectively some good and bad examples.

For extra info on this matter, learn our posts taking a look at how agile creative can improve email marketing and highlighting case studies that investigate where to place your CTA to maximise conversions...

Don’t use too many buttons

Assuming that your e-mail marketing campaign has a selected objective, it’s advisable to concentrate on one or perhaps two calls-to-motion.

This avoids complicated the recipient and retains their thoughts targeted on the job in hand.

A case study from Whirlpool exhibits that when the model lowered the variety of CTAs in its e mail from 4 right down to only one, it achieved a forty two% improve in clicks.

Originally the marketing staff had stuffed the emails with CTAs based mostly on the idea that extra buttons equals extra clicks.

However all 4 CTAs associated to separate actions, which distracted from the main focus of the e-mail, which was to drive customers to a rebate touchdown web page and encourage them to go to a showroom.

Make them stand out

A good CTA wants to face out from the remainder of the e-mail and seize the consumer’s consideration.

This could be a tough activity when entrepreneurs should take into consideration present model color schemes and templates, however there’s multiple method to catch an individual’s eye.

For instance, should you’re choosing a button relatively than a textual content hyperlink, be sure that there’s loads of area across the CTA and don’t place it in the midst of a load of textual content.

I’m undecided about this instance from Reiss. It stands out towards the blue background and positively matches with the model picture, however I’d have an interest to see whether or not a button had higher influence.

I additionally counted greater than 4 CTAs on this e mail alongside a lot of different hyperlinks, which might probably dilute the impression.

Click to enlarge

This effort from Threadless is barely higher as there’s a persuasive, time restricted supply and a transparent CTA.

However there are nonetheless numerous buttons and the e-mail itself is so vibrant that it’s troublesome for the buttons to not conflict.

Click to enlarge

This artistic from Topshop is sort of poor – it’s a month-to-month publication with the topic line ‘What’s scorching in June’ so one would anticipate it to have a whole lot of content material, however the textual content and CTAs are all the identical color so nothing actually jumps out.

Click to enlarge

Write brief, persuasive copy

As the identify suggests, the job of a CTA is to encourage the reader to carry out a specific motion.

To assist obtain this think about using punchy, direct copy to create a way of urgency and stir your clients into motion.

In the instance above Threadless has opted for ‘Buy now’, which is about as succinct and direct as you will get.

Similar choices embrace:

  • Shop Now
  • Download Now
  • Buy
  • Shop
  • Start your free trial

Test it!

These ideas are solely meant to behave as steerage and inspiration in your personal e-mail marketing efforts, they don't seem to be onerous and quick guidelines.

All points of your e-mail content material must be examined to seek out out what works on your marketing efforts.

And even whenever you’ve discovered a profitable method, carry on testing new concepts or the outcomes might find yourself diminishing over time.

Now, let's check out some good and bad examples of e-mail CTAs from some B2C manufacturers...

The Good

New Look

How’s this for a easy, targeted e mail message?

Are you prepared for the World Cup? If not, store New Look’s males’s or ladies’s ranges. It does appear to be lacking two apostrophes there although.


Another nice instance of how one can create a easy, efficient e-mail CTA. There’s a sale on, so click on the button to buy it.

Mr Porter

The CTA itself doesn’t bounce out at you on this instance from Mr Porter, however I am a fan of the straightforward artistic.

This e-mail has an extra 10 ’Shop now’ buttons additional down the e-mail, which is probably a number of too many.

Rue La La

It could possibly be argued that this CTA is a bit obscure, as the e-mail is promoting a sale however the copy says ‘Shop trend’.

However I just like the simplicity of the artistic and the language used to create urgency: “You have 24 hours. And... go.”


This CTA stands out towards the remainder of the content material and is surrounded by loads of white area.

On the draw back, it was the featured promotion in an e mail that had the topic line: “Vans Star Wars and new Nike.”


ASOS’s emails are typically fairly succinct and I like that the distinction of this CTA towards the white background.

Though you possibly can just about click on on something on this e-mail to entry the sale.

The Bad


This instance from Macy’s is bonkers. The topic line advertises Father’s Day present concepts, however then the primary hyperlink is for ladies’s merchandise and there’s additionally a hyperlink for purses.

It looks like there’s a bit an excessive amount of happening and some too many product managers demanding to get their share of the pie.

And this isn’t even your complete e mail, there are five different promos beneath this one.


Reiss sticks faithfully to its white, textual content CTAs, which maintains a constant model picture however means they will sometimes be troublesome to see.

In this instance I assume it’s straightforward to miss the CTA towards the sunshine background.

Macy’s Again

Sorry to maintain harping on about Macy’s, however this e-mail is extraordinarily cluttered. I didn’t even discover the promo code the primary couple of occasions I checked out it.

It’s additionally adopted by an enormous quantity of different content material selling homewares, furnishings, cologne and even mattresses.


Although the CTA stands proud, there’s an excessive amount of textual content on this e-mail and there’s not sufficient to encourage the recipient to truly click on on something.

Currys additionally falls sufferer to the lure of cluttering its e mail with far too many various provides and promotions additional down.

The Whisky Exchange

I really feel bad together with this e mail as The Whisky Exchange is usually very good, nevertheless on this occasion there principally aren’t any CTAs. I assume you simply click on on the image...

One ultimate Macy’s e mail

Another busy, busy e-mail from Macy’s, this time with a complicated choice of presents.

The field on the left gives you an additional 20%, 15% and 10% off - which is it? Or you will get $10 off. Or there’s a web-based unique deal on the backside for 25% off clearance merchandise.

Super Saturday positive is a complicated time down at Macy’s.

Leave a Reply